So i took a sapphire and got all of my rings as i leveled (water, lev, fire, and passwall) but when i noticed i messed up the build i decided to reincarnate, but when i reclaim my bound items i dont get my rings... please help.
The logs say you only had a Water Breathing ring on you when you reincarnated. Are you sure you weren't thinking of a different character? You have two characters reincarnated with almost exactly 500k XP (as if you had used a sapphire).
You can also exchange L35 rare weapons at Borian to acquire your rings.