Responsive posts SHOULD contain any of the following:
1. Suggestions for alterations in statistics, with the reason for the changes. 2. Critique as to the 'item the suggested item would be replacing', if you believe the OP is overlooking something.
They SHOULD NOT contain debate about anything not directly related to the above items. If you want to debate game design, or class edits, or anything not DIRECTLY related to making the OP's suggested item into a workable piece of set loot, post in the appropriate forum, and not here.
Posts should be short and to the point. This is a forum directed at a specific goal.
Posts should be respectful of the OP. Constructive criticism can be hard to do on the tone-deaf medium of the printed word, so err on the side of caution.